Earning From Your Spare Key
By Brian Jacobs
Picture a lake house that you own in two versions of the same story. In both of them, you spend the same two weeks there every August, sitting on the same porch and looking out at the same water. The only thing that separates the two stories is what you do with the spare key when you head home. In one version it goes into a kitchen drawer, and in the other it goes into a lockbox by the door.
The lockbox house gets rented out while you are away. Most Sundays the guests leave behind a pile of wet towels and $600 in rent, which is a pretty good trade for a house that would otherwise be sitting empty. Then one Sunday they leave behind a ruined couch, and replacing it costs $1,800. A weekend that was supposed to earn $600 instead put you $1,200 in the hole. Two weeks later, there is a kitchen fire, which is a different matter entirely, and why you have used a little of the rent money along the way to buy an insurance policy. You handle the couch yourself, and you pay for it out of pocket, while for a major fire the policy can help cover outsized repairs.
I use this analogy to explain an overlay strategy that usually takes a full slide deck to explain. Both houses are exactly the same from a core perspective, but one of the two has additional return streams that require a second set of books.
The Second Ledger
Picture the two houses as portfolios. Both of them start with the same market exposure (i.e., the house in the above example), which I will call the core, and the rented portfolio keeps a second ledger alongside it. On that ledger, the strategy collects a premium for selling short-dated options, including puts on stock indexes, to collect a premium (i.e., the rent) that someone wants to hand off for a few weeks to de-risk and is willing to pay for the privilege.
In a flat or rising market, those premiums collect and add to whatever the core earns. In a moderate selloff, the losses on the options you sold likely eat up the premium and then some, which is the ruined couch showing up in portfolio form. The fire coverage is real as well because the strategy also buys calls on volatility, meaning if volatility spikes those calls can gain value and offset some of the losses in a severe downturn. How much they offset depends on the size of the move and on when it lands.
The core can be almost anything. The same second ledger can sit on top of a short-term bond portfolio just as easily as a stock portfolio because the overlay does not much care what the house is made of. What changes from one market to the next is which part of the ledger is doing the work.
This Idea Has a History
If this sounds familiar to anyone with more than 20 years of market experience, it should. In the mid-2000s, the big idea in institutional investing was alpha/beta separation, usually sold under the name portable alpha. The pitch went like this: market exposure is cheap, so get it through futures or swaps, then spend the real money on a separate manager whose returns supposedly have nothing to do with the market and stack the two on top of each other. You keep the beta and port the alpha over.
It lost most of its shine when the alpha turned out to be beta wearing a costume. It was correlated with the market, it was often illiquid, and it drew down at exactly the moment the core was drawing down and the futures positions needed cash. The whole structure rested on two questions that nobody could answer ahead of time, namely whether the manager was actually skilled and whether that skill would show up in the particular year you needed it.
Structural, Not Alpha
The second ledger we run is built on a different premise. We are not claiming any skill at picking which options to sell. We are collecting a premium that exists because of how people behave, and that premium has a long record behind it. Investors have historically paid more for short-dated protection than that protection ended up being worth; the buyer is paying for peace of mind, and the extra compensation is a risk premium. Risk premiums get paid for taking a risk, not for being clever about it.
That distinction matters more than it sounds like it should. Alpha has to be re-earned every single year by a person, while a structural premium only needs the demand for insurance to persist, and that demand has been there through a lot of very different markets. It also means the terms are known going in, because the rent is roughly the same size each week and the couch is a known kind of loss. You are not hoping that somebody is good at their job. You are agreeing to a trade whose shape you can see before you sign.
Repeatable is the word I keep coming back to. Portable alpha was hard to repeat because it depended on something scarce; we think this is easier to repeat because it depends on something common.
What It Actually Costs
None of this is free, and the lake house is honest about that in a way fund marketing often is not. Most weeks you collect, and some weeks you pay out more than you took in. A moderate selloff is the version of the couch where the option losses outrun the premium, and that is simply the trade. The volatility calls are the policy with the high deductible, paid for out of the rent, with no help at all on the couch and meaningful help on the fire, and the exact amount of that help depends on how hard and how fast volatility moves. The policy can also fall short: in a fast drop where the volatility spike comes late or not at all, the losses on the sold puts can outrun both the premium and the hedge.
So the question for an advisor is not whether this is alpha. It is not, and we would rather you not think of it that way. The question is whether you want the core you already own to carry a second ledger whose payoff you understand before the year starts. That is the lockbox decision, and three things belong in it:
What is the rent? The premium being collected, measured against the core it sits on, is the closest thing the second ledger has to a known number.
What does the couch cost? A moderate selloff is where the trade pays out, and the size of that bill is set by how much is being sold, not by anyone’s forecast.
What does the policy cover? Volatility calls are built for the fire, so the question is how much of a sharp move they can offset and what they cost to carry in the quiet years.
The house is the same house it has always been. The only decision is what to do with the key.
Disclosures
Past performance is not indicative of future results. This material is not financial advice or an offer to sell any product. The information contained herein should not be considered a recommendation to purchase or sell any particular security. Forward looking statements cannot be guaranteed. Hypothetical examples are for illustrative purposes only, do not reflect the deduction of fees or expenses, and are not indicative of any actual investment result. The lake house example and the charts shown are hypothetical illustrations of a concept and do not represent any fund, strategy, index or actual results. Options involve risk and are not suitable for all investors. Selling options can expose a portfolio to losses that exceed the premium received, and purchased options can expire worthless, resulting in the loss of the entire premium paid. There is no guarantee that any options strategy will achieve its objective or offset losses in the underlying portfolio.
This commentary offers generalized research, not personalized investment advice. It is for informational purposes only and does not constitute a complete description of our investment services or performance. Nothing in this commentary should be interpreted to state or imply that past results are an indication of future investment returns. All investments involve risk and unless otherwise stated, are not guaranteed. Be sure to consult with an investment & tax professional before implementing any investment strategy. Investing involves risk. Principal loss is possible.
Advisory services are offered through Aptus Capital Advisors, LLC, a Registered Investment Adviser registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. More information about the advisor, its investment strategies and objectives, is included in the firm’s Form ADV Part 2, which can be obtained, at no charge, by calling (251) 517-7198. Aptus Capital Advisors, LLC is headquartered in Fairhope, Alabama. ACA-2611-22.
The Investment Hub carries the full Aptus research library — manager research, market dashboards, models, and a studio that renders it all on your firm's letterhead.
Sign in Request access